Debunked: Article Claims Eating Meat Is Better For Muscle Health In Old People


3 Minutes Read

High intake of animal protein may weaken bones and increase the risk of fractures (Photo: Adobe. Do not use without permission) - Media Credit:

There has been more contradictory tosh in the mainstream media this week, with a recent Daily Mail headline claiming that Meat-eating boosts muscle health better than plant-based diets as we age – but don’t buy it.

The story says that vegans need to eat a lot more grains, pulses and beans if they want to get the same protein benefits that meat, dairy and eggs offer to ageing bodies. 

There is no mention of how harmful to health animal protein is and no discussion of the huge health benefits vegan diets offer. 


On average, men need around 55 and women 45 grams of protein daily – most people in the UK get more than enough. Government surveys suggest that the average daily intake for most is at least 130 percent of the recommended amount. 

Too much protein – especially from animal foods – can be harmful and high intakes have been linked to disease and early death. High intake of animal protein may also weaken bones and increase the risk of fractures. 

Animal protein .v. plant protein

The idea that animal protein is superior to plant protein is not supported by the evidence; a review in the journal Nutrients says that the question of any amino acid deficiency in plant foods has been substantially overstated and that the term ‘complete protein’ is misleading. 

They suggest that it’s time to shift away from unnecessary questions about protein adequacy of vegetarian diets. Put simply, if your varied vegan diet provides enough energy, it will provide enough protein. 

Older people require less energy because the basal metabolic rate (the number of calories you need to keep your body functioning) falls with age. As a result, there can be a tendency for some older people to fall short on protein, regardless of diet; this can lead to loss of muscle – sarcopenia. 

Too much protein – especially from animal foods – can be harmful (Photo: Adobe. Do not use without permission)

Vegan sources of protein

There are plenty of excellent, healthy, vegan sources of protein such as pulses (peas, beans, lentils and tofu), nuts and nut butters, seeds and wholegrain foods. If you compare the protein in 100g of scrambled egg (around two eggs) to tofu, the eggs provide around 11 grams but the tofu may give you up to a whopping 23.5 grams but without the cholesterol and saturated fat. 

For an extra boost try snacking on nut butter on oatcakes, add tahini to salad dressing and nibble some cashew nuts in the afternoon! It is nonsense to suggest that vegans are more likely to feel the effects of aging bodies by not eating meat; vegans have healthier levels of fat in their blood, a lower risk of chronic disease and tend to live significantly longer than meat-eaters. 

Years of advertising and marketing meat, fish, eggs and dairy foods have created this myth that animal protein is best – the opposite is true. If you eat a healthy and varied vegan diet, protein won’t be on your worry list. 

Find out more about protein and which plant foods are best here and read Viva!’s health feature Muscle without meat

This article was originally published by Viva!

Support Plant Based News in our mission to plant 1 million trees by 2030. 🌳

Your donation supports our mission to bring you vital, up-to-the-minute plant-based news and research and contributes to our goal of planting 1 million trees by 2030. Every contribution combats deforestation and promotes a sustainable future. Together, we can make a difference – for our planet, health, and future generations.

© 2023 Plant Based News is a UK-based digital media outlet publishing content about veganism and plant-based living, including news and current events, health, personal transformation stories, features, and recipes. | Plant Based News Ltd, PO Box 71173, London, SE20 9DQ, United Kingdom.