Snopes Debunks Claim That Plant-Based Meats Are ‘Indistinguishable’ From Dog Food

'One could make a similar argument that the ingredients in high-quality, organic beef dog food are 'nearly indistinguishable' from canned beef chili served in the supermarket'


1 Minutes Read

plant-based meats from Impossible and Beyond In 2020, many consumers tried vegan options when they couldn't find their usual products in stores - with many saying they would stick with the plant-based alternatives - Media Credit: Adobe. Do not use without permission

Fact-checking site Snopes has debunked the claim that plant-based meats are ‘indistinguishable’ from dog food. 

The false statements come from University Professor Frank Nitloehner. Last year, he tweeted the ingredient list of three food items.

The first was from Impossible Foods, the other a Beyond Meat burger, and lastly ‘premium dog food’. 

Nitloehner then argued the meat-free patties were ‘indistinguishable from dog food’. 

The comparison

However, Snopes compared the ingredients – taking ‘some chemical liberties and ignoring entirely the relative amounts of each’. 

It found most of the shared ingredients are vitamins and minerals. This includes ingredients such as salt, Riboflavin (Vitamin B2), and Pyridoxine Hydrochloride (Vitamin B6). 

‘Mostly false’

Snopes concluded: “In sum, there are shared chemicals in vegan dog food and plant-based burgers. 

“In our view, two shared ingredients out of a combined 46 (in the case of Beyond Meat) or 10 shared ingredients out of a combined 48 (in the case of the Impossible Burger) do not meet the threshold for being ‘indistinguishable’. As such we rank the claim mostly false.”

Snopes also questioned what ‘scientific point’ Nitloehner’s comparison served. 

“One could make a similar argument that the ingredients in high-quality, organic beef dog food are ‘nearly indistinguishable’ from canned beef chili served in the supermarket,” it wrote. “But such a comparison wouldn’t be all that illustrative.”

You can read the full report here

Join The Plant Based Newsletter and we will plant a tree! 🌳

We plant a tree for every signup. You’ll receive our weekly news round-up and be the first to hear about, product launches, exclusive offers and more!

© 2023 Plant Based News is a UK-based digital media outlet publishing content about veganism and plant-based living, including news and current events, health, personal transformation stories, features, and recipes. | Plant Based News Ltd, PO Box 71173, London, SE20 9DQ, United Kingdom.